Step 1

Failed Step 1? What to Do Next

The retake rules, how to read your score report, how long to wait, and what to change so the second attempt is different from the first.

· 7 min read · IvyMed

The short version

  • You are not alone: about 1 in 14 first-time US MD students did not pass Step 1 in 2025
  • You may take a Step up to 4 times in total, and no more than 3 times in 12 months
  • Most students who retake pass: 71% of US MD repeaters did in 2025
  • Do not rebook until two recent NBME forms are clearly above the low-pass range

First: this happens, and it is recoverable

In 2025, 93% of first-time US MD students and 89% of first-time DO students passed Step 1, according to the USMLE. For first-time students from schools outside the US, it was 75%. So every year thousands of capable students are exactly where you are now.

Most of them pass on the retake. In 2025, 71% of US MD students repeating Step 1 passed, and 54% of repeaters from non-US schools did.

Take a few days off before deciding anything. Then tell your school. Your dean’s office has seen this many times and knows your deadlines and options.

The retake rules

These come from the USMLE Bulletin of Information:

  • You may attempt each Step at most 4 times in total, counting incomplete attempts.
  • You may not take the same Step more than 3 times within 12 months.
  • A fourth attempt must be at least 12 months after your first attempt and at least 6 months after your most recent one.
  • Once you pass a Step you cannot retake it.

Your school may be stricter

Many medical schools set their own limits on attempts and on how soon you must retake. Check your school’s policy before you pick a date.

Read your score report

A failing Step 1 report shows how far you were from the passing standard and how you did in each content area compared with a low-pass performance. That tells you two things: how big the gap is, and where it is.

A small gap with one or two weak areas calls for a targeted plan of a few weeks. A larger gap spread across many areas means rebuilding foundations, and that takes longer.

How long to wait before the retake

Let practice scores set the date, not the calendar. Rebook when two recent NBME forms in a row, taken timed, are clearly above NBME’s example low-pass range of about 61–67%.

Take a fresh NBME two to three weeks into your new plan to see whether the changes are working. If the score has not moved, change the plan again before you spend more weeks on it.

What to change this time

Doing the same plan again, harder, is the most common mistake. Change how you study:

  • Review by concept: for each miss, name the concept and the look-alike answer you chose, not just the right letter.
  • Do timed, mixed blocks every day so switching topics feels normal.
  • Fix the weakest two or three content areas on your score report first.
  • Practice in the real format: 30-minute blocks of up to 20 questions.
  • Keep one rest day a week. Tired studying is slow studying.
  • Get a second pair of eyes. A tutor can see the pattern in your misses faster than you can alone.

What about residency?

The attempt stays on your USMLE transcript, and programs will see it. The best answer to it is a clear pass on the retake followed by a strong Step 2 CK score, which programs weigh heavily now that Step 1 has no number.

Questions students ask

How many times can you take Step 1?
Up to 4 attempts in total, counting incomplete attempts. After four attempts without passing, you are not eligible to apply for any USMLE Step.
How soon can I retake Step 1 after failing?
The USMLE allows up to 3 attempts at the same Step within 12 months; a fourth must be at least 12 months after the first and 6 months after the most recent. Your school may set its own rules.
What percent of students pass Step 1 on a retake?
In 2025, 71% of US MD students and 79% of DO students repeating Step 1 passed, and 54% of repeaters from non-US schools, according to USMLE performance data.
Will failing Step 1 keep me from matching?
The attempt stays on your transcript, and programs will see it, but it does not end your chances. A clear pass on the retake and a strong Step 2 CK score matter most.
Should I get a tutor after failing Step 1?
It often helps, because a retake needs a different plan. A tutor reads your score report and practice exams with you and finds the pattern in your misses.

Like how we break these down? Our tutors teach the same way.

Ivy Step 1 tutors go concept by concept with you, find the gaps your practice exams keep exposing, and build your plan around your test date. It starts with a free strategy call.

Book a free Step 1 strategy call How Step 1 tutoring works

Keep reading

All posts

USMLE®, NBME®, MCAT®, SAT®, ACT® and other names mentioned are trademarks of their owners, who are not affiliated with and do not endorse Ivy Tutoring, LLC or IvyMed.